If you advise charitable clients in your practice, you are no stranger to the IRS’s requirements for substantiating charitable deductions.
In some cases, however, the focus on valuing the gift and filing Form 8283 can make it easier to overlook another important requirement: the “contemporaneous written acknowledgment.” As a recent Tax Court case illustrates, that omission can have significant consequences. In Wells v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-49, the issue arose in connection with a claimed charitable deduction carryover stemming from a gift of Mississippi real estate to a nonprofit organization.
The property had been appraised at $4.42 million. And there was plenty of documentation surrounding the gift. The taxpayers had an appraisal. The property was transferred by deed. The charity’s president sent a letter thanking the donors and referencing the property’s appraised value. The taxpayers also filed a Form 8283.
So what went wrong?
The charity’s acknowledgment letter did not state whether the organization had provided any goods or services in exchange for the contribution. The IRS requirements are specific:
A donor claiming a deduction of $250 or more is also required to obtain and keep a contemporaneous written acknowledgment for a charitable contribution. To be contemporaneous, the written acknowledgment must generally be obtained by the donor no later than the date the donor files the return for the year the contribution is made. The written acknowledgment must state whether the donee provides any goods or services in consideration for the contribution.
Specifically, Internal Revenue Code Section 170(f)(8)(C) requires the donor to obtain the acknowledgment by the earlier of (1) the date the donor actually files the tax return for the year of the gift or (2) the return’s due date, including extensions.
In the Wells case, the contemporaneous written acknowledgment was missing a critical required statement. Although the taxpayers argued that their various documents, considered together, were enough to substantiate the contribution, the Tax Court disagreed. The statutory acknowledgment requirement had not been satisfied, and the charitable deduction carryovers were disallowed.
For advisors, Wells is a valuable reminder that the mechanics of charitable giving deserve just as much attention as the strategy. This is especially important when clients are giving real estate, closely held business interests, or other noncash assets where the deductions can be substantial and additional substantiation requirements may apply.
When you’re helping a client make a significant charitable gift, it can be worth taking a close look at the entire charitable-gift file. A deed, appraisal, Form 8283, or friendly thank-you letter may not necessarily check every box. Careful coordination among the client, advisors, and charitable organization can help identify documentation issues while there is still time to address them.
The defect in Wells was fixable, but only if someone had caught it in time. Again, Internal Revenue Code Section 170(f)(8)(C) says that the donor must obtain a compliant acknowledgment by the earlier of (1) the date the donor actually files the tax return for the year of the gift or (2) the return’s due date, including extensions.
Consider what might have happened if Wells’s tax advisors had reviewed the charitable-gift file while preparing the 2016 return and noticed that the nonprofit’s letter didn’t say whether goods or services had been provided in exchange for the property. The solution to this particular problem may have been straightforward: contact the nonprofit and obtain a corrected or supplemental written acknowledgment containing the missing statement before filing the return.
Consider what might have happened if Wells’s tax advisors had reviewed the charitable-gift file while preparing the 2016 return and noticed that the nonprofit’s letter didn’t say whether goods or services had been provided in exchange for the property. The solution to this particular problem may have been straightforward: contact the nonprofit and obtain a corrected or supplemental written acknowledgment containing the missing statement before filing the return.
Cases like Wells are one reason our team at the Lenawee Community Foundation values working alongside professional advisors early in the charitable planning process. When your clients are considering gifts of complex assets to a donor-advised or other type of fund at the Foundation, we can help navigate the charitable side of the gift while you and your client’s other advisors guide the legal, tax, and financial considerations.
The strategy matters. So do the details. We’re honored to be a resource when charitable giving becomes part of the conversation.